[Oa-italia] Fwd: [Icolc] Done DEAL: All German research articles in Wiley journals to be published open access under new transformative agreement
Monica Marra
monica.marra a inaf.it
Mer 16 Gen 2019 12:30:43 CET
Purtroppo i due testi non sono accessibili al momento, tuttavia la
definizione citata appare gia' esplicativa. Il problema, come spiegava
Tennant, e' definire quali sono i "values" e quali attori contribuiscono
a definirli. Attualmente, a mio avviso, il quadro e' tutt'altro che chiaro.
Saluti,
Monica Marra
Il 16/01/2019 12.10, Colleen Campbell ha scritto:
>
> Propongo velocemente due interventi di Ellen Finnie, MIT Libraries,
> sulla loro implementazione di “values-based decision making”. Gli
> editori hanno i loro obiettivi, ma siamo noi che scegliamo come
> investire i nostri fondi.
>
> http://intheopen.net/2016/03/what-organic-food-shopping-can-tell-us-about-transforming-the-scholarly-communications-system/
>
>
> https://intheopen.net/2018/06/mit-rsc-read-and-publish-agreementn-access-mit-and-the-royal-society-of-chemistry-sign-first-north-american-read-and-publish-agreement/
>
> *From:*OA-Italia [mailto:oa-italia-bounces a openarchives.it] *On Behalf
> Of *Monica Marra
> *Sent:* Wednesday, 16 January 2019 11:35
> *To:* oa-italia a openarchives.it
> *Subject:* Re: [Oa-italia] Fwd: [Icolc] Done DEAL: All German research
> articles in Wiley journals to be published open access under new
> transformative agreement
>
> A mio parere il tentativo di far passare trasformative agreements a
> livello globale dice quanto basta sugli obiettivi dei maggiori
> editori in termini di business.
>
> Ha scritto Jon Tennant, che propone un'analisi ampia e condivisibile,
> individuando un problema di consenso sul concetto di OA:
>
> "(...) the fact that many commercial entities consider Open Science to
> be a business model is quite divergent from the original purposes and
> intents, for example outlined in the Budapest Open Access Initiative
> <https://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/09/budapest-open-access-initiative.html>.
> Similarly, much of the political motivation for Open Science in Europe
> <https://ec.europa.eu/research/openvision/index.cfm> sees it as a
> mechanism for innovation and economic growth. However, if one deems
> Open Science to include value-based dimensions such as equity,
> justice, as well as technical factors like open source, then many
> services that superficially appear to support open scientific
> practices are divergent from it in other ways. In fact, the Open
> Science community has yet to appropriately decide on what these core
> values behind (open) research are, and how this translates from good
> scientific practices and norms established in a non-digital age."
>
> L'articolo, che consiglio, puo' essere letto per intero a
> http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2018/11/22/do-we-need-an-open-science-coalition/
>
>
>
> Monica Marra
>
>
>
> Il 16/01/2019 10.31, Tessa Piazzini ha scritto:
>
> Sicuramente è una grande notizia, della quale noi beneficeremo di
> riflesso (potendo leggere più articoli in OA), ma di cui subiremo
> anche le conseguenze (saremo sempre meno competitivi e non
> allineati con le evoluzioni che si stanno delineando).
>
> Sui "trasformative agreements" e, in particolare, sul modello
> "Publish&Read" al momento, però, ho numerose perplessità:
> 1. come impedire la crescita esponenziale delle APC (così come già
> successo per il "subscription model")
> 2. rischi etici sulla peer review
> 3. aumento del divario tra paesi o istituzioni "ricchi", che
> possono permettersi di pagare per pubblicare, e contesti "poveri".
>
> Buona giornata
>
> Tessa Piazzini
>
> Responsabile del Servizio di informazione e comunicazione all'utenza
>
> Biblioteca Biomedicahttp://www.sba.unifi.it/biomedica
>
> Responsabile Gdl SBA per l'accesso aperto e il supporto alla valutazione della ricerca
>
> Membro della Commissione di Ateneo per l'accesso aperto ai prodotti della ricerca
>
> Università degli studi di Firenze
>
> Largo Brambilla 3
>
> 50134 Firenze
>
> tel. 055 2751375/1370
>
> fax 055 2751382
>
> e-mail:tessa.piazzini a unifi.it <mailto:tessa.piazzini a unifi.it>
>
> Blog Bibliomedica In-forma:www.bibliotecabiomedica.wordpress.com <http://www.bibliotecabiomedica.wordpress.com>
>
> Il 15/01/2019 14:17, Maria Cassella ha scritto:
>
> Vi giro questa mail di importanza estrema dal cellulare.
>
> Si commenta da sola. È il primo passo.
>
> Saluti alla lista
>
> Maria Cassella
>
> ---------- Messaggio inoltrato ----------
> Da: *Ralf Schimmer* <Schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de
> <mailto:Schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de>>
> Data: martedì 15 gennaio 2019
> Oggetto: [Icolc] Done DEAL: All German research articles in
> Wiley journals to be published open access under new
> transformative agreement
> A: "icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org
> <mailto:icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org>"
> <icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org <mailto:icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org>>
>
>
> ***with apologies for cross-posting***
>
> Dear ICOLC-Colleagues,
>
> In case you have not yet seen the news, Germany's Projekt DEAL
> and the publisher John Wiley & Sons have entered a
> ground-breaking transformative agreement, in line with the
> objectives of the Open Access 2020 initiative:
> https://www.hrk.de/press/press-releases/press-release/meldung/wiley-and-projekt-deal-partner-to-enhance-the-future-of-scholarly-research-and-publishing-in-germany/
>
> Under this new agreement, all authors affiliated with 700
> academic institutions in Germany will retain copyright and
> their accepted articles will be published open access in Wiley
> journals. Almost 10,000 articles by German researchers are
> published a year in Wiley journals, constituting around 9% of
> the publisher's total output. The agreement also grants
> students and faculty read access to the full Wiley journal
> portfolio including backfiles starting with 1997. The
> national-level agreement is based on a "Publish&Read" model in
> which fees are paid by institutions-not for subscriptions but
> for open access publishing services.
>
> The agreement will be made public in a month's time and an
> English-language FAQ will be released by the Projekt DEAL
> working group.
>
> I will be attending the Vancouver ICOLC meeting and would be
> happy to present/discuss this and perhaps other
> ground-breaking transformative agreements that may materialize
> between now and then.
>
> Best wishes,
> Ralf
> Transformative agreements are those contracts negotiated
> between institutions (libraries, consortia) and publishers
> that transform the business model of scholarly communication
> in which the parties are engaged from subscription to open
> access. They allow institutions to remove their financial
> support of paywalls and shift their investments to support
> open access publishing, thus ensuring maximum impact for the
> research they produce and ongoing and unencumbered access to
> knowledge for their faculty and students. Because the vast
> majority of scholarly publishing currently happens in journals
> produced by a relatively small number of commercial
> publishers, transformative agreements with these publishers,
> in particular, constitute a high-impact strategy, in line with
> the objectives of the Open Access 2020 initiative, to
> accelerate the transition of scholarly communication to open
> access. From an administrative perspective, transformative
> agreements unlock the opaque, lump-sum payments to
> publishers for reading access-largely based on legacy print
> expenditures-and, instead, articulate fees for services at the
> article level; this shift brings cost transparency to the
> scholarly publishing marketplace, enables market competition
> to contain pricing, and disbands the lump-sums fees of
> subscriptions so that investments are free to follow authors
> as they determine the publishing venues most appropriate for
> their work-a necessary step on the path to a diverse ecosystem
> in scholarly communication. For more information on
> transformative agreements, see http://esac-initiative.org/
> <http://esac-initiative.org/>.
>
> --
> Dr. Ralf Schimmer
> Max Planck Digital Library (MPDL)
> Amalienstr. 33
> 80799 Muenchen, Germany
> Tel. +49 89 38602-261
> Fax +49 89 38602-290
> Email: schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de
> <mailto:schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de><mailto:schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de
> <mailto:schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de>>
> http://www.mpdl.mpg.de
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> icolc mailing list
> icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org <mailto:icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org>
> http://lyralists.lyrasis.org/mailman/listinfo/icolc
>
> Emails to this list should be considered restricted to
> consortia and library personnel and should not be forwarded or
> shared with vendors verbatim or with attribution.
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
>
> OA-Italia mailing list
>
> OA-Italia a openarchives.it <mailto:OA-Italia a openarchives.it>
>
> https://liste.cineca.it/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/oa-italia
>
> PLEIADI:http://www.openarchives.it/pleiadi/
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
>
> OA-Italia mailing list
>
> OA-Italia a openarchives.it <mailto:OA-Italia a openarchives.it>
>
> https://liste.cineca.it/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/oa-italia
>
> PLEIADI:http://www.openarchives.it/pleiadi/
>
> --
> Monica Marra
> INAF - Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica
> Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio
> v. Gobetti 93/3
> I-40129 Bologna, Italy
> Scopus author ID: 7102382905
> uff. 3W1
>
> _______________________________________________
> OA-Italia mailing list
> OA-Italia a openarchives.it
> https://liste.cineca.it/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/oa-italia
> PLEIADI: http://www.openarchives.it/pleiadi/
--
Monica Marra
INAF - Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica
Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio
v. Gobetti 93/3
I-40129 Bologna, Italy
Scopus author ID: 7102382905
uff. 3W1
-------------- parte successiva --------------
Un allegato HTML è stato rimosso...
URL: <http://liste.cineca.it/pipermail/oa-italia/attachments/20190116/33405092/attachment-0001.html>
Maggiori informazioni sulla lista
OA-Italia