[Oa-italia] Fwd: [Icolc] Done DEAL: All German research articles in Wiley journals to be published open access under new transformative agreement

Colleen Campbell campbell a mpdl.mpg.de
Mer 16 Gen 2019 12:10:05 CET


Propongo velocemente due interventi di Ellen Finnie, MIT Libraries, sulla loro implementazione di “values-based decision making”. Gli editori hanno i loro obiettivi, ma siamo noi che scegliamo come investire i nostri fondi.

http://intheopen.net/2016/03/what-organic-food-shopping-can-tell-us-about-transforming-the-scholarly-communications-system/
https://intheopen.net/2018/06/mit-rsc-read-and-publish-agreementn-access-mit-and-the-royal-society-of-chemistry-sign-first-north-american-read-and-publish-agreement/


From: OA-Italia [mailto:oa-italia-bounces a openarchives.it] On Behalf Of Monica Marra
Sent: Wednesday, 16 January 2019 11:35
To: oa-italia a openarchives.it
Subject: Re: [Oa-italia] Fwd: [Icolc] Done DEAL: All German research articles in Wiley journals to be published open access under new transformative agreement


A mio parere il tentativo di far passare trasformative agreements a livello globale dice quanto basta  sugli obiettivi dei maggiori editori in termini di business.

Ha scritto Jon Tennant, che propone un'analisi ampia e condivisibile, individuando un problema di consenso sul concetto di OA:

"(...) the fact that many commercial entities consider Open Science to be a business model is quite divergent from the original purposes and intents, for example outlined in the Budapest Open Access Initiative<https://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/09/budapest-open-access-initiative.html>. Similarly, much of the political motivation for Open Science in Europe<https://ec.europa.eu/research/openvision/index.cfm> sees it as a mechanism for innovation and economic growth. However, if one deems Open Science to include value-based dimensions such as equity, justice, as well as technical factors like open source, then many services that superficially appear to support open scientific practices are divergent from it in other ways. In fact, the Open Science community has yet to appropriately decide on what these core values behind (open) research are, and how this translates from good scientific practices and norms established in a non-digital age."

L'articolo, che consiglio, puo' essere letto per intero a http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2018/11/22/do-we-need-an-open-science-coalition/



Monica Marra


Il 16/01/2019 10.31, Tessa Piazzini ha scritto:

Sicuramente è una grande notizia, della quale noi beneficeremo di riflesso (potendo leggere più articoli in OA), ma di cui subiremo anche le conseguenze (saremo sempre meno competitivi e non allineati con le evoluzioni che si stanno delineando).

Sui "trasformative agreements" e, in particolare, sul modello "Publish&Read" al momento, però, ho numerose perplessità:
1. come impedire la crescita esponenziale delle APC (così come già successo per il "subscription model")
2. rischi etici sulla peer review
3. aumento del divario tra paesi o istituzioni "ricchi", che possono permettersi di pagare per pubblicare, e contesti "poveri".

Buona giornata

Tessa Piazzini

Responsabile del Servizio di informazione e comunicazione all'utenza

Biblioteca Biomedica http://www.sba.unifi.it/biomedica

Responsabile Gdl SBA per l'accesso aperto e il supporto alla valutazione della ricerca

Membro della Commissione di Ateneo per l'accesso aperto ai prodotti della ricerca

Università degli studi di Firenze

Largo Brambilla 3

50134 Firenze

tel. 055 2751375/1370

fax 055 2751382

e-mail: tessa.piazzini a unifi.it<mailto:tessa.piazzini a unifi.it>

Blog Bibliomedica In-forma: www.bibliotecabiomedica.wordpress.com<http://www.bibliotecabiomedica.wordpress.com>
Il 15/01/2019 14:17, Maria Cassella ha scritto:
Vi giro questa mail di importanza estrema dal cellulare.
Si commenta da sola. È il primo passo.
Saluti alla lista
Maria Cassella

---------- Messaggio inoltrato ----------
Da: Ralf Schimmer <Schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de<mailto:Schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de>>
Data: martedì 15 gennaio 2019
Oggetto: [Icolc] Done DEAL: All German research articles in Wiley journals to be published open access under new transformative agreement
A: "icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org<mailto:icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org>" <icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org<mailto:icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org>>


***with apologies for cross-posting***

Dear ICOLC-Colleagues,

In case you have not yet seen the news, Germany's Projekt DEAL and the publisher John Wiley & Sons have entered a ground-breaking transformative agreement, in line with the objectives of the Open Access 2020 initiative: https://www.hrk.de/press/press-releases/press-release/meldung/wiley-and-projekt-deal-partner-to-enhance-the-future-of-scholarly-research-and-publishing-in-germany/

Under this new agreement, all authors affiliated with 700 academic institutions in Germany will retain copyright and their accepted articles will be published open access in Wiley journals. Almost 10,000 articles by German researchers are published a year in Wiley journals, constituting around 9% of the publisher's total output. The agreement also grants students and faculty read access to the full Wiley journal portfolio including backfiles starting with 1997. The national-level agreement is based on a "Publish&Read" model in which fees are paid by institutions-not for subscriptions but for open access publishing services.

The agreement will be made public in a month's time and an English-language FAQ will be released by the Projekt DEAL working group.

I will be attending the Vancouver ICOLC meeting and would be happy to present/discuss this and perhaps other ground-breaking transformative agreements that may materialize between now and then.

Best wishes,
Ralf
Transformative agreements are those contracts negotiated between institutions (libraries, consortia) and publishers that transform the business model of scholarly communication in which the parties are engaged from subscription to open access. They allow institutions to remove their financial support of paywalls and shift their investments to support open access publishing, thus ensuring maximum impact for the research they produce and ongoing and unencumbered access to knowledge for their faculty and students. Because the vast majority of scholarly publishing currently happens in journals produced by a relatively small number of commercial publishers, transformative agreements with these publishers, in particular, constitute a high-impact strategy, in line with the objectives of the Open Access 2020 initiative, to accelerate the transition of scholarly communication to open access. From an administrative perspective, transformative agreements unlock the opaque, lump-sum payments to
 publishers for reading access-largely based on legacy print expenditures-and, instead, articulate fees for services at the article level; this shift brings cost transparency to the scholarly publishing marketplace, enables market competition to contain pricing, and disbands the lump-sums fees of subscriptions so that investments are free to follow authors as they determine the publishing venues most appropriate for their work-a necessary step on the path to a diverse ecosystem in scholarly communication. For more information on transformative agreements, see http://esac-initiative.org/.

--
Dr. Ralf Schimmer
Max Planck Digital Library (MPDL)
Amalienstr. 33
80799 Muenchen, Germany
Tel. +49 89 38602-261
Fax +49 89 38602-290
Email: schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de<mailto:schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de><mailto:schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de<mailto:schimmer a mpdl.mpg.de>>
http://www.mpdl.mpg.de



_______________________________________________
icolc mailing list
icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org<mailto:icolc a lyralists.lyrasis.org>
http://lyralists.lyrasis.org/mailman/listinfo/icolc

Emails to this list should be considered restricted to consortia and library personnel and should not be forwarded or shared with vendors verbatim or with attribution.



_______________________________________________

OA-Italia mailing list

OA-Italia a openarchives.it<mailto:OA-Italia a openarchives.it>

https://liste.cineca.it/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/oa-italia

PLEIADI: http://www.openarchives.it/pleiadi/



_______________________________________________

OA-Italia mailing list

OA-Italia a openarchives.it<mailto:OA-Italia a openarchives.it>

https://liste.cineca.it/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/oa-italia

PLEIADI: http://www.openarchives.it/pleiadi/

--

Monica Marra

INAF - Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica

Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio

v. Gobetti 93/3

I-40129 Bologna, Italy

Scopus author ID: 7102382905

uff. 3W1
-------------- parte successiva --------------
Un allegato HTML è stato rimosso...
URL: <http://liste.cineca.it/pipermail/oa-italia/attachments/20190116/2fe487ae/attachment-0001.html>


Maggiori informazioni sulla lista OA-Italia